Skip to main content

Defining Terrorism – Recommendations

The Defining Terrorism review makes 7 recommendations:

The increasing diversity of terrorist causes has revealed uncertainty about what 'ideology' means. A definition of 'ideology' with the following features should be enacted:

Ideological means of, or relating to, an ideology;

Ideology means a set of beliefs or ideas, that may or may not be coherent, that relate to how the world or society is, or should be, understood.

Example: Beliefs or ideas include those based on nationalism, politics, faith, philosophy or the superiority of one group over another.

This definition makes the word 'religious' legally redundant. It should be removed from the definition. Requiring proof that an act was intended to advance a religious cause glorifies and gives false credibility to offenders and stigmatises religious communities. Those claiming to be acting for a religious cause will still be able to be effectively prosecuted. There are also potential benefits for social cohesion and counterterrorism initiatives from this change.

Making a credible threat to commit an act of terrorism can cause significant fear and distress and should remain a crime. But it is disproportionate, unnecessarily complex and out of step with international standards for the making a threat to be a life imprisonment offence with a mandatory minimum sentence of 6 years.

The words 'threat of action' should be removed from the definition, and a separate offence should be created in Part 5.3 of the Criminal Code that applies to making a threat to commit a terrorist act in circumstances where a reasonable person would fear the threat would be carried out. The maximum penalty should be no more than 15 years. Police powers to respond to, what at the relevant time is believed to be a risk of a terrorist attack, will be unaffected.

To be consistent with our international obligations and our Five Eyes partners, the definition should specifically apply to acts done to coerce or influence by intimidation a public international organisation.

Victim-survivors of terrorism experience both mental and physical harm. Mental harm is already considered at sentencing. Extending the definition to include all situations that cause mental harm alone would lead to real practical difficulties in applying special terrorism powers and is not recommended. The exception is hostage taking where the person taken hostage is not physically harmed.

(a)        To provide clarity and avoid unintended overreach, serious risks to health or safety should be amended to read 'serious risk to physical health or safety'. This should apply to both paragraphs (2)(e) and (3)(b)(iv).

(b)        To close a small gap in Australia's definition and to reflect international best practice, hostage taking or unlawful deprivation of liberty should be added to the list of terrorist harms.

To comply with international norms, improve proportionality and ensure counterterrorism resources are well focused, damage to property and electronic systems should only fall within the definition of a 'terrorist act' when an action:

(a)        causes damage to property or interference with an electronic system that is likely to cause serious physical harm to a person, endanger life, cause death or create a serious risk to physical public health and safety;

(b)        causes serious damage or serious disruption to critical infrastructure; or

(c)        causes extensive damage to places of significant cultural value.

Critical infrastructure should be defined to include electronic systems and in a way that limits it to: telecommunications and financial systems; essential government services and public utilities; public transport systems; and defence facilities and assets.

A definition of 'places of significant cultural value' could be developed based on international instruments and existing laws that protect such places.

If this recommendation is not accepted, then 'intimidating' should be raised to 'seriously intimidating' in paragraph (c)(ii) of the definition to provide at least some safeguard against property damage being overly broad.

Exclusions from what is considered terrorism have an important role in limiting extraordinary offences and powers.

(a)        The protest exclusion should be retained and amended to ensure that actions that are intended to result in self-harm only are covered by the exclusion.

(b)        To ensure Australian law is consistent with our counterterrorism convention obligations as well as international humanitarian law, we should have an exclusion in the definition of a terrorist act for conduct occurring during an armed conflict that is governed by and in accordance with international humanitarian law.

(c)        To protect the work of impartial humanitarian organisations undertaking exclusively humanitarian activities from coming within the scope of terrorism training, funding, support and financing offences, targeted exemptions for these offences should be introduced.

There is an alarming increase in the number of children being prosecuted for terrorism related offences. Given the complexity of this issue, an independent and thorough review (or coordinated reviews) is required. Three areas of focus should be: the effectiveness of interventions to reduce the risk of children becoming radicalised; if additional regulatory measures are required to assist in reducing children being targeted online or exposed to violent extremist material; and, whether the current legal framework contains appropriate safeguards, including having regard to the Convention on the Rights of the Child.