INSLM Audio-Visual Explainer – Property damage
ANITA COLES: Hi, I'm Anita Coles, Principal Legal Advisor at the INSLM Office, and I'm joined by Jake Blight, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor. We're recording today on Ngunnawal country and wish to pay our respects to elders past, present and emerging and to the traditional owners of the lands, wherever you may be listening from. We're here today to talk about the Monitor’s recent report on the definition of terrorism.
So, Jake, can you explain how our terrorism laws currently apply in relation to property damage?
JAKE BLIGHT: Currently serious damage to any property and serious interference with any electronic system can amount to terrorism if it's done to advance a relevant cause and coerce or intimidate the government or public. This could include any type of property, regardless of its value, for example, a car, or perhaps even a sign, and to any cyber-attack, even a hack on a company database.
Now these things are bad and they are serious crimes under other laws, but it's disproportionate to also treat them as terrorism given all the consequences that flow from an act being classified as terrorism, including up to life imprisonment. And Australia is an international outlier in this space. Most other countries, including most of our five eyes partners, limit terrorism by property damage to situations where people might be killed or seriously injured.
And I think it's time we amend our law to ensure that property damage has a clear and confined scope.
ANITA COLES: So what are the changes you're proposing in relation to this?
JAKE BLIGHT: Most terrorism involves actual or planned harm to people. Property damage likely to seriously harm people must remain within the definition. We also need to cover attacks on critical infrastructure such as telecommunications, banking, essential government services and utilities, as well as defence facilities and assets. So those will stay in. To ensure that attacks on places like churches, synagogues, mosques and Indigenous sacred sites remain covered, I have recommended also including extensive damage done to places of significant cultural value. Remember, of course, that like any terrorism, you also have to prove that the property damage was done to advance a relevant cause - so it wasn't just for profit or for personal grievance - and that the act was intended to coerce a government or intimidate a section of the public.
Because terrorism is about why something was done as well as what the damage was.
ANITA COLES: So what impact do you think these changes will make?
JAKE BLIGHT: Well, it's not proportionate for our terrorism laws, including life imprisonment offences, to apply to things like seriously damaging a car if no one will be hurt. And police have told me that they wouldn't really prosecute something as terrorism that didn't harm people or only caused minor property damage. So to police it won't make much difference. But really, it's our Parliament that needs to set these boundaries, not the police.
And this change will give greater certainty as to what is and is not to be treated as terrorism. It'll also help ensure that our counterterrorism resources remain focused on the most serious threats. Our regular police and the ordinary criminal law are able to deal effectively with other types of property damage.
ANITA COLES: Thank you. This is one of a series of short recordings about this review. Check the others out on the INSLM website, where you'll also find the actual report and a short summary of it. Thanks for your time.