INSLM Audio-Visual Explainer – Other recommendations
ANITA COLES: Hi, I'm Anita Coles, Principal Legal Advisor at the INSLM Office, and I'm joined by Jake Blight, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor. We're recording today on Ngunnawal country and wish to pay our respects to elders past, present and emerging and to the traditional owners of the lands wherever you may be listening from. We're here today to talk about the Monitor’s recent report on the definition of terrorism.
So, Jake, in some of the other recordings, we've talked about ideology, religion, property and children, but you've made some other recommendations as well. One of your recommendations is to make a new offence for threatening to commit an act of terrorism. Can you explain what that means?
JAKE BLIGHT: Making a threat to commit a terrorist act is currently treated the same as planning or actually carrying out an attack. It's kind of the difference between sending an email, which can be a threat, versus actually building or planting a bomb. Sending a threat is serious. It can be very distressing and it can draw on agency resources, but it shouldn't be a life imprisonment offence. So I'm suggesting creating a separate new offence with an appropriate sentence for making threats.
ANITA COLES: Okay. Would this change how police respond to what might be a terrorist attack?
JAKE BLIGHT: No, it would not. If police think there is a risk that an attack will occur, then their powers are enlivened. If down the track, their investigation shows that your threat is actually part of a plan to actually go ahead and commit an act of terrorism, then you're still going to be liable to be charged with the life imprisonment offence of preparing or planning to commit a terrorist attack.
ANITA COLES: Okay, you've also made a recommendation about harm to a person's mental health. Can you explain that one?
JAKE BLIGHT: Look, clearly, a terrorist act where people are injured or killed will cause not only physical harm, but will also likely cause ongoing and significant mental harm to victim-survivors, loved ones, witnesses and first responders. This harm is real and it's serious, and it's already something that courts consider when deciding what sentenced to impose on a convicted terrorist. And nothing in my review will change that.
But some submissions to my review argued that harm to a person's mental health alone should be treated as a terrorist offence. That would mean that if an act caused no physical harm to people or property, but caused serious mental harm, for example, a doxxing campaign, it could be treated as terrorism if it meets the other criteria. I considered that carefully, but I've concluded that acts that cause mental harm alone are better dealt with by other laws.
For example, doxxing’s already an offence, as is displaying prohibited symbols and a range of other things, but to also treat it as terrorism would cause real practical difficulties and uncertainty in applying special terrorism powers and offences. For example, to use special powers police would have to make rapid judgments about the impact of an unfolding incident on mental health, when those effects can often take some time to manifest and will require diagnosis by mental health experts. There is one exception to this and that relates to hostage taking, where I do see a small gap in our current terrorism laws.
ANITA COLES: Okay. And what's that gap and what do you recommend?
JAKE BLIGHT: Well, in the vast majority of cases, taking hostages will endanger the lives of those taken hostage. And this type of situation is already covered by our terrorism laws. But there is a small gap if people are held against their will, but they're not actually in danger of coming to serious physical harm. For example, if people are lured somewhere and then locked in by the offenders but not physically harmed. I think it's important to close this gap.
Hostage taking needs to be clearly within the definition of terrorism.
ANITA COLES: You've also made a recommendation about specifically including international organisations as targets of terrorism. Why is that?
JAKE BLIGHT: Well, this is another small gap. Currently, our definition of terrorism refers to acts done to coerce or influence by intimidation an Australian or foreign government. Now, this doesn't apply to acts done to coerce or intimidate an international organisation such as the UN. This would mean that if we were hosting a meeting of the UN, for example, and an attack was carried out against it as an organisation, it would not necessarily fall under our terrorism laws. So I’ve recommended that these organisations be captured as potential targets of terrorism. This is what most of our partners do as well.
ANITA COLES: So there are some exclusions that you've outlined in the report's recommendations. Can you talk us through some of them and why you felt it important to highlight them?
JAKE BLIGHT: Well, currently we have an exclusion from terrorism for acts of advocacy, protest, dissent or industrial action so long as they're not intended to cause serious harm to people. This is important and should be retained. Protest, even unlawful protest, isn't terrorism. People who are protesting might commit other crimes if, for example, they damage property, but this isn't what our terrorism laws are for, and that's always been the case.
I've also recommended that it be made clear that we're talking about harming other people. And so if a person self-harms during a protest, for example, a hunger strike, then this shouldn't be terrorism either. There's also an issue of principle regarding when the special laws of war should apply rather than crimes such as terrorism. And I've made a fairly technical recommendation there.
It won't come up very often. In fact, it would not have applied in any of our terrorism cases to date. But it is something we have a chance to fix if we're making other changes.
ANITA COLES: Okay. And finally, you've also made a recommendation about impartial humanitarian organisations. What is it you're trying to achieve there?
JAKE BLIGHT: Well, while you wouldn't think that terrorism laws could apply to impartial humanitarian organisations, there are some terrorism offences that can affect them. For example, the Red Cross has a mandate to provide training on international humanitarian law to all armed groups. Yet if that armed group is a proscribed terrorist organisation, then the Red Cross workers could be committing the offence of providing training to a terrorist organisation.
Similarly, in distributing humanitarian aid, they may technically fall foul of laws that make it an offence to indirectly make funds available to a terrorist organisation. And the Red Cross told me that these offences are impacting their humanitarian work, with some people not willing to deploy to conflict zones because of the risk that they may commit a crime, and also the cost and delay involved in organisations trying to assess whether providing humanitarian aid might be an offence. As such, I've recommended an exemption be provided for exclusively humanitarian activities of such organisations from four specific terrorism offences.
ANITA COLES: Thank you. This is one of a series of short recordings about this review. Check the others out on the INSLM website, where you'll also find the actual report and a short summary of it. Thanks for your time.