Skip to main content

INSLM Audio-Visual Explainer – Overview of INSLM and the review

  • Audio
Publication date

ANITA COLES: Hi, I'm Anita Coles, Principal Legal Advisor at the INSLM Office, and I'm joined by Jake Blight, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor. We're recording today on Ngunnawal country and wish to pay our respects to elders past, present and emerging and to the traditional owners of the lands wherever you may be listening from. We're here today to talk about the Monitor’s recent report on the definition of terrorism.

So, Jake, could you explain to us what is the role of the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, we have a lot of national security laws in Australia. They're complex, and they contain some of the nation's most serious offences and most invasive powers. And many of these powers are exercised by agencies that operate in secret. The role of the Monitor is to independently review our national security and counterterrorism laws, to assess if they're effective, proportionate and have effective safeguards and comply with our international obligations, including human rights obligations.

To do this work, I have access to classified material as well as extensive engagement with civil society groups and national security agencies. I make recommendations for law reform and these get tabled in the Parliament.

ANITA COLES: So you've just finished a review into how our laws define terrorism. Can you explain why you undertook this review?

JAKE BLIGHT: There are three factors. The first is the sheer passage of time. It's 25 years since the definition was enacted. The second is that in that time there's been a really significant change in the threat environment. There's also, and this is the third factor, been a significant increase in the volume and intrusiveness of the laws attached to that definition.

The change in the threat environment is really significant. For example, 25 years ago the threat was almost entirely from Al-Qaeda. Now, at least a third of ASIO and AFP investigations are racist, nationalist and other ideologies. Al-Qaeda was international, organized, well-funded. But now attacks are most likely to come from individuals born in Australia using basic weapons with basic plans.

They mostly act alone, and they're inspired by online material, and an alarming number of them are children. This definition of terrorism sits at the very heart of our counterterrorism regime. We need the very best definition we can have for today and for the future. It isn't enough to say that the definition has worked in the past.

ANITA COLES: So can you explain to us how terrorism is different to other crimes?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, everything that's a terrorist act is also another crime. It's always been a crime to murder people, to cause grievous bodily harm, to burn buildings down. These are and remain very serious crimes. We've also got newer crimes that overlap with terrorism, such as advocating hate against a group based on particular characteristics. And all victim-survivors of all violent crimes carry a terrible burden.

But victim-survivors of terrorism carry an extra burden. They bear the weight of being targeted for what is actually an attack on all of us. And that's because terrorism is different to other crimes. To prove a terrorist act requires three things. First, that the act be done with the intention of advancing a political, religious, or ideological cause. And second, that it be to coerce or influence by intimidation a government or the public, or a section of the public.

And third, that it causes a certain level of serious harm to people, property or electronic systems. Finally, terrorism doesn't apply to protest, advocacy, dissent, or industrial action, so long as there's no intention to seriously harm people. So yes, terrorism is a special category of crime. It is complex and harder to prove than other crimes. But it should be because the powers and penalties attached to it are extreme.

ANITA COLES: When was the current definition enacted?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, terrorism, as it appears in our Criminal Code, was introduced in 2002, in the wake of the 9/11 attacks. You've got to remember that 9/11 was an attack of really profound significance in Australia and internationally. And at the time, we realized that if an attack like that happened here, no one state police force could predict or deal with it.

Normally, under our constitutional system, crimes are dealt with by the states. But the scale of 9/11 made all the states refer their power to the Commonwealth, so that we could have federal laws and a coordinated approach, one that involved ASIO and our federal police and our intelligence agencies, as well as the state police. 9/11 was not a normal crime and the response was not a normal criminal one.

So we have this special set of laws for extreme threats, things that threaten not only individuals, but our society as a whole. Our constitutional system, our way of life and our terrorism laws modified long-held principles like the presumption of innocence, by changing rules like the presumption of bail. We made laws to keep people in jail even after their sentence was complete if we thought they might still pose a terrorist risk, we made changes to allow people to be detained for longer without charge, to compulsorily question people, even those not suspected of committing a crime. We even brought in a preventive detention regime. These are not normal laws in a democracy. They are exceptions. We must not forget that we have these laws to protect our democracy, and we need to keep them confined to doing what is essential to respond to the extraordinary threats of terrorism.

Otherwise, we risk undermining the very democracy we seek to protect.

ANITA COLES: So how have you conducted this review?

JAKE BLIGHT: We spoke to well over 100 organisations and experts from across civil society, faith-based groups, academics, lawyers, police, policy agencies both in Australia and internationally. We've received submissions from these organisations and many members of the public. We also undertook extensive legal research and analysis, we looked at how our definition compares with other countries, we held public hearings to test preliminary recommendations.

And then a bit later on, we thoroughly tested the recommendations with police and security agencies. We considered classified examples and other things to make sure that they would work in practice and have the overall result of improving our counterterrorism scheme.

ANITA COLES: So you've completed your review. What happens next?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, we provided the report to the Commonwealth Attorney-General on the 20th of October 2026, and it's now been tabled in Parliament and is available on the INSLM website. It will now take a while for government to consider the recommendations. With this report and the upcoming report from the Royal Commission, the government has a unique and valuable opportunity to deeply consider the legal and social framework around terrorism, and to ensure we have a clear and modern definition that protects the Australian community from current and emerging threats and supports social cohesion.

I do think we need to act promptly to modernize our definition, but it isn't a simple exercise. It requires coordinated federal, state and territory action, and that will take some time. It's a lengthy report and governments do need time to review it. I did a lot of consultation, but I expect more will now occur behind the scenes as governments work through the report. And that can't be rushed.

ANITA COLES: Thank you. This is one of a series of short recordings about this review. Check the others out on the INSLM website, where you'll also find the actual report and a short summary of it. Thanks for your time.