Skip to main content

INSLM Audio-Visual Explainer – Ideology and religion

  • Audio
Publication date

ANITA COLES: Hi, I'm Anita Coles, Principal Legal Advisor at the INSLM Office, and I'm joined by Jake Blight, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor. We're recording today on Ngunnawal country and wish to pay our respects to elders past, present and emerging and to the traditional owners of the lands wherever you may be listening from. We're here today to talk about the Monitor's recent report on the definition of terrorism.

Jake, your report focuses on ideology as a key component of the terrorism definition. Why is that? And what is an ideology?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, with terrorism, the prosecution has to prove that your violence was intended to advance a political, religious or ideological cause. This is unusual because normally, as a matter of law, it doesn't really matter what you were intending to achieve by committing a crime. If you intentionally kill someone, it's murder. But using violence to advance a cause that is intended to rally others behind the same cause is a key part of terrorism.

It can lead to more violence, and this makes terrorism particularly dangerous and different to other crimes. The problem is that the meaning of ideology is currently not very clear. This hasn't really mattered for prosecuting those who seek to promote the causes of groups like ISIS. Juries have never really doubted that ISIS wants to advance their political, religious and ideological agenda.

But terrorism is not only committed by those who support ISIS. In fact, around a third of the AFP and ASIO's current caseload is not ISIS related. These racist, nationalist and other ideologies have only had about a 50% conviction rate. That's really low. The conviction rate for ISIS type terrorism is about 84%. And I'm worried that if we don't act to modernise our legislation, then we're going to have an ongoing disparity in the conviction rate between ISIS and other ideologically driven terrorism.

That's a problem and one that needs to be addressed soon. The number of these cases is growing really rapidly.

ANITA COLES: Okay. So what is it that you're recommending should change?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, I think we need a statutory definition. I think we should say that ideology is a set of beliefs or ideas that may or may not be coherent, that relate to how the world is or should be understood. For example, sets of ideas based on nationalism, politics, faith, philosophy, or the superiority of one group over another. This is expansive enough to capture both the old and new types of threats.

For example, it'll clearly cover racist, nationalist, incel and other emerging ideologies. And it'll also cover ISIS. But remember, you still have to show that the violent act was intended to advance an ideological cause, not just that they happen to have an ideology and committed a crime. Our definition of terrorism is 25 years old, and we need to modernise it so that our counterterrorism police can respond effectively to these new types of threats, as well as the enduring threat from ISIS.

ANITA COLES: Okay, that makes sense, but can you explain why you've recommended removing the word religious alongside having a definition of ideology? There's often a lot of talk about so-called religiously motivated terrorism.

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, first, it's important to remember that terrorism is about advancing a cause. And that's a bit different to having a motive. But yes, we have people who commit terrorism in Australia to advance what they describe as religious causes. And mostly this is individuals inspired by ISIS. They remain a real threat. They're not going away anytime soon, and we still need to be able to investigate and prosecute them.

ANITA COLES: But given this, wouldn't many people say we need to keep the word religious?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, there might be a small risk if what we did was just remove the word religious. But that's not what's proposed. I think we need to add a definition of ideology at the same time. And this new definition will cover ISIS and others, including those who commit terrorism claiming to be Christian or to represent any other religion. Remember, ideology is going to be defined as a set of beliefs or ideas that may or may not be coherent, that relate to how the world is or should be understood.

For example, sets of ideas based on politics, nationalism, faith, philosophy, or the superiority of one group over another. In other words, for this purpose, religious beliefs are just one form of ideology. And no one I spoke to during this review, including police, lawyers, officials, and other experts, could provide me with a single example of a religion that does not include a set of beliefs or ideas that relates to how the world is or should be understood.

And we've spent a long time thinking about the legal consequences of this. There really isn't any legal risk of ISIS followers getting away from charges of terrorism by claiming that ISIS isn't advancing an ideology.

ANITA COLES: What about the argument that we should 'call it what it is' - that the terrorists themselves said that they're acting to advance a religious cause?

JAKE BLIGHT: They do. They claim to be acting in their God's name, to be doing holy work. That's what they use to justify their crimes and to try and recruit others to their cause. It's also exactly why we should not be agreeing with them. When our prosecutors have to prove that an act was intended to advance a religious cause, we're giving them exactly what they want - a platform which reinforces their narrative and gives them false credibility.

Really, I think the message we want our law to send is that what they're doing is terrorism. It's a crime, and that it isn't in a special religious category. They're not special. We don't need to acknowledge or reinforce that they think it's holy work. Just send them to jail as violent ideologues under exactly the same provision that will jail neo-Nazis and others who commit violence to advance an ideological cause and intimidate the public.

ANITA COLES: Okay so do you think that shifting this language by reframing ISIS as just another violent ideology, would this change the views of those who are already committed terrorists?

JAKE BLIGHT: No. Look, it probably won't change their views if they're already deeply committed. But it's the next generation that we also need to be worried about. There's a really alarming growth in the number of children being radicalised to violence, and we don't want to do anything to inadvertently give credibility to the claims of ISIS and others when they say that they've got a legitimate religious cause.

Language matters. And this is one of the reasons to modernize our definition. We've done this with other laws. For example, our laws don't refer to child pornography anymore. We call it child abuse material. And if someone kills their sister believing it's necessary to protect the family's honour, we don't charge them with honour killings. We charge them with murder.

We don't even call it a king hit. We call it a coward's punch. Language does matter. But there's also a bigger picture here about stigmatization and disengagement. We are living in a time of fractured social cohesion that can't be fixed by making a law, but we can make sure our law isn't inadvertently contributing to the problem. I heard from many religious groups, including, but by no means only from the Muslim community, that over the last 25 years, the practical effect of this provision has been to contribute to the conflation between terrorism and Islam.

And that leads to stigmatisation. I don't think that was the intention of this provision, but this effect is not helpful. It doesn't help counterterrorism efforts, and it contributes to isolation and disengagement. That narrative may even contribute to some of the violence, including terrorist violence directed at religious minorities. We don't need the word religious in our law to effectively prosecute terrorists, and it isn't helping counterterrorism efforts.

And it could well be harming social cohesion. So we really need to remove it.

ANITA COLES: Okay. And what's the position internationally on this?

JAKE BLIGHT: Well, there's no universal agreement on how to define terrorism. But the very latest guidance from the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Countering Terrorism is that the word religious should not be included, because the practical reality is that in many countries, conflating religion and terrorism has done more harm than good.

ANITA COLES: Okay and what impact do you think that this would have on counterterrorism, policing and investigations?

JAKE BLIGHT: Look, it won't dictate how or what police investigate as terrorism. And it certainly won't take anything away from existing efforts against ISIS and similar groups, but it will have some practical benefits. First, the new definition of ideology will help our agencies combat the rising problem of racist, nationalist and other emerging ideologies. This is about a third of their current caseload and it isn't shrinking.

Secondly, if managed well, this change could be a real boost for relations between counterterrorism agencies and religious groups. It would be a real confirmation that our Parliament supports religious and faith communities, but stands firm against anyone using violence to advance a cause. And finally, police and security agencies need everyone to understand that contemporary terrorism is broader than the stereotype and that they want people to report radicalisation and potential terrorist threats of all types.

I want to be clear that bringing in the necessary new definition of ideology without removing the then legally redundant word religion, would actually compound existing problems, including stigmatisation of Muslim Australians and giving terrorists false credibility. And that's why I expressly recommend against that approach. So for all these reasons and more that are detailed in the full report, we need to modernize our definition, including a clear definition of ideology and subsuming religious causes into this broader category of ideological causes.

ANITA COLES: Thank you. This is one of a series of short recordings about this review. Check the others out on the INSLM website, where you'll also find the actual report and a short summary of it. Thanks for your time.